Coma

Feb 27 2008  | Views 642 |  Comments  (26)
Coma... Expand

Leave a Comment   Flat Nested


  tanushri podder posted 5 mnths ago

excellent narrative of two dissimilar characters...liked the characterisations very much...



  KUNAL MUNSHI posted 5 mnths ago

EVERYTHING WE DO CRUMBELS DOWN TO GROUND AND YET WE DO, MAY BE IN ORDER TO ACHIVE , OR MAY BE IN ORDER TO SURVIVE,,(A PERSONAL CHOICE). 

YOU SET YOURSELF A TASK, 
ACHIVE IT, 
AND YOU BECOME A WINNER.
ELSE,
YOU ARE A LOOSER.

WHAT IF YOU HAVE NO TASK TO BE SET , 
THEN WHAT ARE YOU ???

YOU ARE NOT A FAILURE COZ YOU DID NEVER  SET TO ACHIVE ANYTHING,
 NEITHER  ARE YOU A WINNER COZ YOU HAVE  NEVER REALLY ACHIVED ANYTHING,
SO IS TONY.

K.M.



  kolipakkam posted 6 mnths ago

After reading the story and going through the comments, I know what exactly I lack - my genome is short by two genes, one for imaginationa and the other for interpretation. I am a "shoot-me-between-the-eyes" kind of fellow and I have absolutely no talent for stringing out parallels &c. I went through the story twice and the stream of comments more times than that; and I think I am finally getting to understand the depth of your thoughts. Hats off to you.

Wonderful narrative (what else can I say)!

Raghuram Ekambaram



  pavementfreud posted 6 mnths ago

Hello Matheikal,

Loved the way you've subtly weaved the tale around the word Coma. The dictionary defines it as 'A decreased state of consciousness from which a person cannot be roused.'  So true for Tony and for Mark...yet in entirely different contexts!

I've noticed how doctors with years of experience progressively become insensitive to their patients...brusque...this holds true for everyone I guess! 

I loved the smooth flow...but too many words in them quotes hampered the read.

Always
PF



  swarajya posted 6 mnths ago

I wonder how the girls were asked to seduce Tony by Father and they failed.Are  Fathers expected to test boys this way?
The brothers of different nature - one prospering without education and the other educated  but contended without much of an ambition.



  Thomas Cherian posted 6 mnths ago

good story...I find tony's view refreshing...why bother ...to him it does not matter...



  Dawn and Dew posted 6 mnths ago

Oh! I really didn't get at the emotional coma of Tony. That's an excellent perception of a character !

From your reply to Lakshmi Mukundan and me, I observed the following:
#A teacher has to create empathy in children and not sympathy for himself. Tony does not even empathize with his suffering brother. He simply remains a sympathy in the minds of his students! Hence, as you rightly said, he could not rise to the level of Hero by founding himself in any established principle of life.#

Apart from that, I never thought that Tony is a hero. Just a weak character has been portrayed with his own shortcomings. I think a story need not be centered only around heroes, (never should it be centered around a villain in the society, of course) but it can also portray a weak character which may enlighten people of similar nature to think a bit about their being. Developed further with Tony's failures, the story may bring out a rich message to such people who create an air of frolic around them and its futile nature. Anyone born in this world should contribute for the betterment of humanity. Remember my quoting of Bharatiyar's verse in one of my previous comments?



  matheikal posted 6 mnths ago

Dear Dawn and Dew, You grasped one aspect of the story perfectly well.  It’s quite obvious that the writer’s sympathies lie with Tony and hence he emerged as the hero for you, as he would for many readers.  Yet is Tony really a hero?  Yes, he does personify the carefree attitude to life, which may become heroic if it was founded on certain deeper values and sense of responsibility coupled with sensitivity.  Tony is unable to rise to that level.  Hence his spiritual or psychological coma. His inability to feel emotions even when his brother lies in ‘physical’ coma reveals Tony’s ‘emotional’ coma. Is Tony’s coma less dangerous than Mark’s?  Well, I’m not sure.

 

Thanks supriyad, You are right, there are very few like Tony any more.  It’s not easy to be even Tony in today’s world.  I would like you to read also my reply to Dawn.

 

Thanks Kalyanee.  The story is very much about “life without living”, as you said it so rightly.

 

LakshmiMukundan, thanks for the comment.  A teacher’s job is certainly painstaking.  But Tony was liked by his students because of his childlike frolicsome nature.  But the world expects people like Tony to rise above that frolic! 



  LakshmiMukundan posted 6 mnths ago

To me this came across as a study of two siblings in the same family environment, with the same religion and upbringing, living life, each in his own way. I did not think Tony was in a coma because he drank to some extent. He was, to everybody's surprise, a good teacher, you wrote. I was a teahcer once and I know it takes hard work and committment  to be a good teacher. So he was definitely involved in his work and life at the school. He did not make as much money as his brother but that was the way he chose to be...........beautifully written with a very realistic and anecdotal backdrop.........the pious attempts of the Fathers to set Tony "right" are quite hilarious!!



  Kalyanee posted 6 mnths ago

Matheikal,
Nice story. Living life without actually living....
Liked the photo in the story too

Kalyanee





Leave a comment

Use rich text editor:


New Delhi, Male
Member Since May 30 2007
© 1998-2008 Copyright Sulekha.com Connecting Indians Worldwide, All Rights Reserved.